Phrasing Dissertation Questions In Education

.pdf version of this page

This review is a collection of views and advice on composing research questions from problem statements. It mostly reads as a list of tips and suggestions.

A research question is the fundamental core of a research project, study, or review of literature. It focuses the study, determines the methodology, and guides all stages of inquiry, analysis, and reporting.

The research question begins with a research problem, an issue someone would like to know more about or a situation that needs to be changed or addressed, such as:

  • Areas of concern
  • Conditions that could be improved
  • Difficulties that need to be eliminated
  • Questions seeking answers

A research problem leads to a hypothesis (H) and/or research question (RQ)

Questions should in some way. . .

  • Be worth investigating
  • Contribute knowledge & value to the field
  • Improve educational practice
  • Improve the human condition

Characteristics of a good research question:

  • The question is feasible.
  • The question is clear.
  • The question is significant.
  • The question is ethical.

From Research Problem to Research Questions and Purpose

Step 1. Draft a research question/hypothesis.

Example: What effects did 9/11/01 have on the future plans of students who were high school seniors at the time of the terrorist attacks?

Example (measurable) Questions: Did seniors consider enlisting in the military as a result of the attacks?, Did seniors consider colleges closer to home as a result?

Step 2. Draft a purpose statement.

Example: The purpose of this study is to determine the effects of the 9/11/01 tragedy on the future plans of high school seniors.

Step 3. Revise and rewrite the research question/hypothesis.

Example: What is the association between 9/11/01 and future plans of high school seniors?

Step 4. Revise andrewrite the research question/hypothesis.

Example: Purpose Statement (Declarative): The purpose of this study is to explore the association between 9/11/01 and future plans of high school seniors.

Note: Both are neutral; they do not presume an association, either negative or positive.

Operationalize

Notice that the above research question suggested an association or a relationship. When composing your own, it is helpful to determine which variables you would like to understand, and then word your question in such a way as to suggest how you will test your question. This is called operationalizing, referring to the actions, processes, or operations used to measure or identify variables.

Finally, you will want to be specific about whom you are studying. Using my example above, “students” is not specific, so I might revise to public high school seniors in the Midwest.

Expanding Simple Research Questions

You can expand your question by introducing additional variables or characteristics. We call these connecting, mediating, or moderating variables.

Example: What is the relationship between 9/11/01 and enlisting in the military?

Variables I might introduce to expand the question include:

  • Demographics (gender/age/ethnicity/religious preference)
  • Geographic location
  • Parent’s educational level
  • Role of parent
  • Student’s /parent’s political affiliation

Common Errors

The Nobel Laureate (taking on your life’s work)

Example: The Effects of 9/11/01 on K-12 students

The term paper (taking on too little)

Example: How many high school seniors enlisted in the military prior to 2002 graduation?

The Black Hole (taking on too much)

Example: The Effects of 9/11/01 on High School Seniors

A Few Good Wording Tips*

1.  When a relationship is expected among a certain type of subject, reference the population.

Example: Among young children, there is a positive relationship between level of psychomotor coordination and degree of self-esteem.

2.  Make RQs and Hs as specific and succinct as possible.

OK: Administrators who provide wellness programs for their employees project positive effectiveness.

Better: Administrators who provide wellness programs for their employees receive higher employee ratings on selected leadership qualities than administrators who do not provide wellness programs.

3. Avoid words or terms that do not add to the meaning of RQs and Hs.

Rather than: Among elementary school teachers, those who are teaching in year-round schools will report having higher morale than those who are teaching in elementary schools that follow a more traditional school-year schedule.

Try: Among elementary school teachers, those who teach in year-round schools have higher morale than those who teach on a traditional schedule.

4. Stick to what will be studied, not implications or your value judgments.

Rather than: Religion is good for society.

Try: Regular attendance at religious services is inversely associated with cheating behavior while taking classroom tests.

5. Name the variables in the order in which they occur or will be measured.

Example. There is a positive relationship between College Board Scholastic Aptitude Test scores and first-semester grades earned in college.

6. Avoid the words significant or significance.

7. Avoid using the word “prove.”

8. Avoid using two different terms to refer to the same variable.

*Note: “Wording” examples are attributed to Dr. Kathy Haywood, UMSL

Like this:

LikeLoading...

Home Schooling Dissertation Topics

Home schooling refers to any time when children are educated at home instead of being enrolled in a public or private school. Here are some further discussions in this area that you could use in your education dissertation.

• Are children who are schooled at home able to handle socially challenging situations?
• Should home schooling be regulated more, and if so, by whom?
• Why is the trend for home schooling on the rise in the UK?
• Children that are home schooled are usually educated by either parent or both parents, instead of a governess or some other trained educator; is this a good thing?
• Children who are home schooled have less behavioural problems than those attending conventional schools. Why?
• Home schooling has more advantages than disadvantages when compared to sending children to a traditional school.
• Students who are home schooled are usually higher achievers than those attending traditional schools.
• Should the increasing trend in home schooling be allowed to continue without any further legislation being passed on regulation and monitoring?
• Should the traditional schooling system be changed to embrace some of the components of home schooling, if so, which aspects would be selected?
• Should traditional schools have programmes where students can participate from home, over the Internet, instead of attending school each day and would that have any impact in the reduction of teenage delinquency, dropout rates and other issues?
• Should home schooled children follow the National Curriculum and if so, why?
• Should home schooling be allowed if the parents are not educated?
• Should all home schooling be monitored by online assessment lessons?
• Is online learning beneficial for young home schooled children, and why?

0 thoughts on “Phrasing Dissertation Questions In Education

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *